| Feature | Hybrid 48V 300A Peak Permanent Magnet Alternator with Scotty AI (HESA) | Traditional 48V 130A Alternator with Wakespeed 500 remote field control. | Winner |
| “Alternator” Type | Hybrid Excitation Synchronous Generator (permanent magnets + hairpin windings) | Field-excited rotor only | BMG |
Rotor Design | 16 permanent magnets + excitation windings | Field windings only | BMG |
Power Density | 1.65 kW/kg (advanced hairpin) | Lower due to round-wire winding | BMG |
IP Level | Brushless Motor: IP25. Waterproof Inverter: IP6K9K | Generally Brushed IP23 or lower | BMG |
Dual Stator Design | Dual three-phase, 30° shifted | Single three-phase | BMG |
Ripple Current Reduction | Significant (30° phase shift) | Higher ripple | BMG |
Noise Vibration Harshness Performance | Optimized (low ripple and torque smoothness) | Higher NVH | BMG |
Efficiency | Higher (permanent magnets + hairpin winding) | Lower (field-excited losses) | BMG |
Fault Tolerance | Dual stator allows operation in partial failure | Single stator, no redundancy | BMG |
| Peak Generator Power | 12 kW | 6.2 kW | BMG |
Peak Efficiency | ≥85% | 60–70% | BMG |
Power at Idle (engine ~600RPM) | 3.0kW | 300-500W Typically | BMG |
Continuous Power Hot | ≥5.5~7.0kW kW | 5~7.0 kW | BMG |
Maximum Speed | 18,000 RPM | ~8,000–10,000 RPM | BMG |
Operating Temperature | -40°C to 105°C | -20°C to 80°C | BMG |
Lifetime Expected | 10 years, 300,000 km, 8,000 hrs | 5–7 years, 150,000–200,000 km | BMG |
| 12V and 48V Isolation Negative side Earth isolated | Yes | No | BMG |
Integration with Factory 12V or 24V Alternator | Full Integration for added power as solar backup at idle | None | BMG |
Diagnostics and Protection Of Load Dumps | Inverter/motor diagnostics, 100% load dump protection | Limited and depends on Battery | BMG |
ISO 26262 ASIL B Automotive Safety Standard | Compliant | Not compliant | BMG |
Insulation Grade | Grade H (180°C) | Grade F (155°C) | BMG |